(This article was translated from Persian by AI.)
3 min.
Why Don’t We Talk?
Hello friends, I am Rasool Shahrad. Here I want to introduce a podcast called the “BPlus” podcast, by Mr. Ali Bandari. One of its episodes — I think it is episode 119, and I will put its link — is about democracy, and it summarizes a very valuable book that is about democracy. I recommend that you definitely listen to this podcast;
But the point that is interesting for me, and that I want to explain here — differently from that book’s discussion — is this: in that book it says that democracy in fact needs something called “dialogue,” and it states the conditions of democracy and the importance of dialogue, and it says that dialogue is not for resolving disagreement; dialogue is so that we understand what the disagreement even is.
When I turn to my own life and look at where disagreements arise — which are in fact those same small disagreements that arise in society — I understand that there are conditions under which people decide not to have dialogue. In this voice message I want to explain and name these, and say what the things really are that cause people not to have dialogue — and anyway, we all know from experience that not talking is, in the end, almost equal to war and loss and the disasters after it.
One of the most important issues in why people do not talk to each other is in fact that same ego that imagines itself separate; that is, we assume that we are separate from others, or we fall into self-superiority and say, “We are not willing to talk to so-and-so because we are superior,” or we fall into self-inferiority and say, “So-and-so would never talk to us anyway,” and we take no step — and this very imagining of ourselves as separate is one of the reasons people in fact do not talk to each other.
Another of its reasons is hopelessness; that is, people very strongly want to reach a certain result, and because they become hopeless of reaching their own result, they become hopeless of talking altogether and are no longer willing to have a dialogue at all; because they want to obtain one specific result and they insist on it — and this is in fact the very root of dictatorship; that is, a dictator is not willing to talk about very many subjects that he himself has decided beforehand; he is not willing to talk, and we are sometimes little dictators who have decided a result beforehand, stand upon it in a completely dictatorial manner, and are no longer willing to talk about it at all, because we say: this is just how it is.
And in fact, before the dialogue, we want to determine the result in advance. I have seen this a great deal in my relationships: people are hopeless, then you say to them, “Why don’t you talk?” They say: “Well, it is of no use, and I will not reach the result I want.” Well, certainly, if you determine the result in advance, you will not reach the result you want; because dialogue in fact means that we come to hear each other and know each other; when you want to determine the result in advance and want to impose your result by dictatorship, you no longer have a dialogue at all.
Other reasons — which are somewhat psychological and emotional reasons why people do not have dialogue — are intense emotions; emotions such as anger, which, if it is in a person, he simply cannot have a dialogue; that is, a person who does not have the ability to control his anger, right at the beginning of the dialogue, after a few sentences, falls into boiling and seething and the like, and simply cannot continue; he either has to throw a punch, or smash himself into the wall — and this is one of the reasons that, with very many people, since they do not have the ability to control their emotions, they give up on dialogue altogether.
Other emotions that exist are sulking — for example, the resentment and sulking that we take toward a person and suppress within ourselves for years, and because this should not come up, and because we do not have the tolerance for these emotions coming up within ourselves, we delete that person entirely inside ourselves and say: “I am not willing to talk to so-and-so at all. Whether so-and-so is dead or alive is all the same to me.” What does this mean? It means: I do not want to experience again the emotions that that person brings into being in me. This too is one of the reasons people do not talk to each other.
So let me summarize once more: why do we not have dialogue? Because when we do not have dialogue, war comes into being — and if we recognize these, we can produce peace, and in fact, the peace and dialogue of democracy begin right here, from knowing its opposite. So look: one is the separate identity and ego — we think we are separate; this being separate creates distance — or we say we are much superior, or we say we are much lower; in both states, we simply do not talk. Then the various emotions: the feeling of hopelessness, the feeling of anger, the feeling of sulking, and the feeling of dictatorship — that we want to determine the result in advance. I wanted to open up this matter here in brief, because I see this a great deal in my own relationships, I see it in society, I see it in countries — that these in fact cause war and destruction and disasters — and how much better that someone speaks about it, and in my view it was necessary for this to be said here.
All of these, too, are rooted in the separate identity — that we see others as separate from ourselves, the false identity that we see as separate from ourselves — and its solution, too, is the practice of oneness: making the ego fainter, and making the boundaries fainter — about which much has been spoken in detail in the Unwritable. I hope this was briefly useful for you; goodbye, and I hope to see you again.
Original (Persian): https://unwritable.org/%da%86%d8%b1%d8%a7-%d8%ad%d8%b1%d9%81-%d9%86%d9%85%db%8c%d8%b2%d9%86%db%8c%d9%85%d8%9f%d8%b5%d9%88%d8%aa%db%8c/