(This article was translated from Persian by AI.)
3 minutes.
I have thoughtful friends who conduct surveys. For example, about the history of Iran, or politics, and so on. The questions of these surveys seemed to me superficial and unimportant. Because the more general a question is, the better it is. For surveying and classifying thoughts and opinions, it is better to start first from general questions, and when we find the general answers, the smaller issues will answer themselves. For example, whether we believe in justice in the world or not constitutes two completely different paths, which also determine the political paths. Also, the options in a survey must be non-combinable and have less in common with each other.
Every survey in fact measures the condition of the public mind in relation to knowing the world. According to my definition, the three topics “world” and “human” and “God” are one. So the general questions must revolve around these topics.
One of the first fundamental questions revolves around the topic of identity and what the human being is. The answer to this question: who am I?
So the first question can be this:
Does something exist beyond the five senses or not? Or, in other words, is there something that is not perceived directly or indirectly by the five senses, yet exists?
For example, electricity exists in a wire and is not perceived directly by the senses, but by bringing an object like a magnet near it, one can perceive the existence of electricity.
This question can also be asked another way. Does something exist other than matter, or not?
Or it can be asked another way. Is the human being something other than the body and thoughts, or not?
Or it can be asked another way. Is death the end of everything? Is death the end of me? After death, does awareness continue, or not?
The answer to this question has two options: yes and no.
If we answer no, we arrive almost at the materialists’ view. From this view, man is an advanced animal. He does the same things animals do. That is: eating, determining territory, mating, reproducing, and dying.
In this state, material sciences such as physics and chemistry become important for overcoming nature. With this assumption, man is defined as a being made of flesh and bone in a jungle called earth. You must eat, lest you be eaten. If you show morality anywhere, it is so that you will not be eaten. That is, fear and lust, or fear and greed, become the two main drives of man. On the basis of this psychology, a material economy is designed, and man can, out of fear and lust and the rest of the instincts, be placed somewhere in the food cycle, just like animals such as mice or lions, and be simulated; and for human collectives, too, like bees and flocks of sheep and wild dogs, laws can be laid down so that society and the food cycle continue their movement.
Qualities such as self-sacrifice can also be defined for the benefit of the group, like fighting bees that sacrifice their lives for their queen or their group.
If we answer yes to the first question, the survey continues. Because one can know the world and the human being more and better.
Suppose we answer yes to the above question. Now the next question concerns the qualities and the knowing of this supramaterial being.
The second question can be this:
Is this supramaterial being intelligent, or not?
The answer to this question is also yes or no.
If the answer is no, we arrive at something like Nietzsche’s theories, who said God is dead. That is, even if there is a god, he is dead and is not intelligent and alive. He must be abandoned, and one must attend to matter and physics and chemistry. But if the answer is yes, more interesting questions can be raised.
The third question is this:
Is this supramaterial being just? Does justice exist in the world?
The answer to this question is also yes or no.
If we do not believe in justice, we return almost to the previous question, because an intelligent being will naturally also be just. So the intelligence of the supramaterial being leads us to this conclusion: that he is just too.
The fourth question is this:
Does the human being — that is, you and I — have free will, or not?
If the answer is no, we arrive at determinism and passivity. And if we lay free will entirely on a superhuman being, we become like the followers of religions and the fascists and sometimes extreme scientism-ists. These accept all the answers beforehand and become slaves and soldiers of a predetermined ideology.
If the answer is yes, then more interesting questions appear.
The fifth question is this:
What is the responsibility of the free human being? Or: to what must the human being be committed? What are the rights and duties of this human being?
The answer to this last question can be the answer to all of humanity’s problems. Which political group to vote for. How to spend our time. What goals to set for our lives, and many of humanity’s endless questions and problems.
✍🏻 Unwritable
www.unwritable.org