September 12, 2024

What Is This Responsibility, After All? – With an Example


Posted on September 12, 2024 by rasool

(This article was translated from Persian by AI.)

4 minutes.

Some people tell me I am irresponsible. My aim here is not to defend myself. But I accept the responsibility of preparing an answer for it.

Responsibility is a concept that is very much misunderstood. A word that people use easily, but no one explains or properly unfolds its meaning.

I had written pieces on the subject of responsibility before, which are here.

The subject of responsibility

https://www.unwritable.net/search/label/مسوولیت?

Now here, in a simpler discussion and with an example, let us imagine two states together.

The first state

Imagine a pupil who, from the very beginning of entering school, has always done what was dictated to him from outside. For example, the school system and the teachers told him: dress like this, walk like this, think like this, write your homework like this, and so on.

He carried out all the orders without question. As a pupil, he did not even have the power to speak, or to give an opinion, or to assert himself — let alone to criticize or oppose.

This pupil gradually grows up. On the same path, he graduates and enters society. In society it is the same. He is well-behaved. He got good grades from school and university.

Then he enters various companies. It makes no difference whether it is a weapons-manufacturing company or, say, the army.

For example, he has become a skilled engineer and has done deep research on metal corrosion at high speeds. His research is used directly in missile-making. Or, for example, he is a skilled pilot of bombing drones. The results of his labors have had an important effect in building war drones.

Or, for example, he has obtained a doctorate and now works for the Amazon company. An Amazon company that is a plague upon the environment. Or for a government company, or, say, a left or right party.

In society’s view, he is successful and responsible, but inside himself he always feels like a victim. He considers the world an unjust place. He believes there is no God in the picture and the world works by chance.

He is always in a deep fear and considers corrupt politicians responsible for his misery. He moves along the path of a society that in his own view is unjust. But he considers himself too incapable to criticize.

He lowers his head and plays the role given to him. But at the bottom of his heart he is dissatisfied with heaven and earth. So dissatisfied that he even denies the existence of a consciousness in the world under the name of God.

Even about the health of his body and mind he relies on the same system. He takes diabetes and depression pills. In his heart he considers himself a victim.

The second state

A person who has quickly left the state of childhood. That is, when he came a little out of the state of childhood and incapacity, he tried to live honestly. He left study and university and went in search of the truth.

He reviewed, and even rewrote, society’s programs for life.

Personally, and with many inner difficulties, he tried to find his own right answer for life. He questioned and examined the institution of marriage and the economic institution existing in the world.

When he understood that such-and-such a company is against the environment, or such-and-such an industry causes the destruction of health, or is a supporter of war, he passed over his own interests and did not go to work. He did not play in the politicians’ playground.

He ultimately considers the world a right place, ultimately governed by a just God.

He has remained faithful to the correctness of his inner compass.

He does not complain about anyone. His state is usually good. He does the work that has meaning for him. He pays no attention to society’s judgments. He is responsible toward his own state.

He exercises and is responsible for his own good state and health.

Unless forced, he does not use the medical system and pills.

He meditates and considers himself responsible for his own good or bad state. He is not affected by insult, humiliation, and rejection by others.

He has taken responsibility for “himself.”

The result

In appearance, the first state seems “responsible” and the second state “irresponsible.”

In the view of the majority, the first person is a responsible and committed person, and the second person an irresponsible person.

While it is completely the reverse.

The first person has responsibility toward the system and is irresponsible toward himself and his inner truth.

But the second person has responsibility toward himself and his inner truth.

The first is committed to outer orders, and the second is committed to the depth of his inside.

In society, however, the first is called committed and dutiful, and the second is called a rebel and uncommitted.

Because in society there is no such thing as inner truth at all, and everyone is assumed to be a sheep and a slave of instincts.

The first, for personal, family, tribal, or national interests, will do anything and receives a medal of honor.

The second, however, for the whole world and his inner truth, takes any risk and is usually rejected by society.

The first is like the cowardly pilot who drops an atomic bomb on Hiroshima and receives a medal of honor and courage from his tribe.

The second is like Edward Snowden, who courageously exposes injustices and is subjected to judicial and criminal prosecution, and a verdict of treason against the tribe is issued for him.

The first is an outward hero and a real coward, but the second is an outward convict but an inner hero.

The first has not taken responsibility for himself and his state and his actions, yet is considered by society a responsible and dutiful person.

The second has taken responsibility for himself and his inner state and his actions, yet is considered a parasite of society, or lazy, or irresponsible.

The first walks and considers others responsible for evils and miseries.

The second acts and considers himself responsible for everything.

The first has a correct appearance but considers himself a victim.

The second, his appearance is real and authentic, but he considers himself a hero.

The first walks and complains to heaven and earth and government and God. He accuses the other of irresponsibility but is not even willing to spend time on it.

The second tries to do something, even a little. Perhaps even just writing about responsibility.

The first has an other-regarding appearance and a self-regarding inner. He surrenders himself to his own personal interests and the oppression of oppressors.

The second has a self-regarding appearance but an other-regarding inner. He devotes himself to the world and the truth.

The first swings a sword in Yazid’s army because he thinks Yazid’s team will win.

The second, knowing he will be killed, swings a sword in the army of truth and even dies.

In short, the difference is from earth to heaven.

These were examples.

I hope I have been able to do a little of my responsibility in writing about responsibility.

Original (Persian)


0