(This article was translated from Persian by AI.)
5 minutes.
Mind-Writings of the India Trip – 6 A Journey into Doubt!
Life at Isha – 24 May
It is about two-thirty in the morning. Yesterday, when I was talking with one of my friends, he said that not only do they read, but they had even gone and searched in Google about the place where I am! That is, these writings are interesting for them! He liked the style of the writings too. That is, writing from the feeling in the moment, without censorship and fear of judgment! A kind of sharing the readers in the path of life! Just as I feel and think! Without change and distortion!
That is how I am writing again. In these two days that I did not write, two events happened. I had a Shambhavi yoga training course, and one day I was free! In the last parts of the two-day class, talk turned to foods with positive energy and foods with negative energy. That is, foods that raise the level of the body’s vital energy, and foods like onion and garlic that cause slackness and a lowering of the energy level. He said, by touch, if you are sensitive, you can understand which food is suitable for you and which is not. But if you could not, there is a hanging pendulum method! It is like this: they have something like prayer beads that is made from the seeds of a tree in the Himalayas. If you hold these beads over foods with positive energy, it turns clockwise. Negative foods counterclockwise, and neutral foods only a linear oscillation! A lemon and a potato and a garlic were also brought for the test! The teacher performed it; it was correct! Lemon clockwise, potato straight, and garlic counterclockwise!! Another person tested it, and the answers were not this correct!! Out of about a hundred students, only I alone dared to say loudly, Sir, I have doubt that this is correct! In my opinion, the intention and the thought of the person who holds the string is the determining factor, not the food beneath it! In short, I finished it off as a joke, and no one from those hundred people pursued it either! The class ended. But the next day this doubt was still with me! You see, I am in a yoga center. Here there is ordinary yoga! There is meditation! And the work goes as far as this: they have made gods from stone and worship them! They say these stones have been given energy! There is someone by the name of Sadhguru who is practically a god! That is, all over this place they have put his pictures and images and footprints, and they truly worship! Sadhguru himself also says that he hopes his followers will offer their lives to him! And truly, many are here who have devoted their entire lives! Various groups, mostly devoted young people, are here! I truly think they are ready to die for their own guru! The utmost sincerity — annihilation and melting away!
The first requirement for beginning the path of the Way is setting aside the logical mind. The same work that I too accept to some extent! That is, the logical mind is exactly like the wooden leg of argument — it is limited. It is constantly reckoning and calculating. But it seems that this logical mind will bring you to peace and happiness only with difficulty!
But there are things in life that truly are beyond the mind! I have a friend who is extremely practical and logical! Having many rights and wrongs. Ordered and tidy! A man of life and family! He knows only the language of logic. So much so that in student days we called him the Iron Man! Yesterday I asked him a question! I said, in your view, is dying right or wrong! You see, there truly are things that cannot be answered with logic! Like dying, and consequently living!
But the property of the mind and logic is like dominoes! That is, if one of the pieces falls, the whole of it collapses! Do you remember the pendulum example! If this one piece falls and it is proven that it is nonsense and fraudulent, the whole story of this temple and even the whole yoga system collapses!
Yesterday I became a little sick and rested more. And I did a little research on this subject! Another person by the name of Deepak Chopra has also done this same experiment with Oprah Winfrey. His interpretation, of course, is closer to mine! He says that with thinking and your mind, you can determine the direction of the beads’ turning. The same thing I am saying! In the end, here perhaps Sadhguru’s interpretation is mistaken!
But Sadhguru is logical in 99 percent of his words! But one percent, or one illogical word, can call his whole credibility into question! This is the property of logic! It builds up on itself! Sadhguru himself says, do not believe anything before you have experienced it yourselves! I am like this too! The path that he himself has gone is also this! He was an atheist man who for ten or twelve years did yoga, by his own saying, for the wrong reason, which was becoming stronger in the body. But he says, if you do the right work even with the wrong intention, it works! The seed of a tree, whoever plants it, with whatever intention, becomes a tree and gives fruit!
Let us arrive at my own inner state! It is ten or twelve years that I do yoga, because it makes my body feel good. After a yoga class, my physical and mental state clearly becomes better! But the higher stages of yoga, which are spiritual and mystical experiences, I have not yet experienced well! From these gods that are made of stone and wood and have been given energy, I feel nothing! I neither reject nor confirm! That is, I remain open for my own experiences! Without concluding! For the mind it is hard, because the mind always wants to draw conclusions!
Concepts like God, spirituality, oneness and so on, before they become part of your own original and inner experience, neither reject them nor accept them! If you accept them without experience, you become ISIS! If you reject them too without experience, you still become ISIS! Of course, multiplied by negative one! Whether its rejection or its acceptance, if it is without personal experience, it is one and the same! A religious person and an atheist are both in one place! They have believed a thing that they do not know!
But here is where I am! Up to here — that the practices of yoga cause a good feeling to come into being in my body and psyche — I have completely and repeatedly experienced! But more, no! That meditation causes my state to become better to some extent, I have also experienced many times! But oneness with the world, no! Giving energy to stone and wood, no!
So I draw a clear border between what I know — that is, have experienced — and what I do not know!
What I know, I know well. But what I do not know, I also know well! I know that I do not know! So I do not blindly believe anything! The highest source of truth is my inner self and my experiences. Not what others say, or what any guru says!
It is true that Sadhguru is extremely intelligent and his arguments are logical. But he too may make a mistake! The prophets, the imams! Rumi! All of them! They too can possibly make mistakes! I do not accept infallibility! As long as a person is human and walks on two legs, he can make a mistake! Even if he is so great and intelligent that he has practically become God! Man apparently has the potential of becoming God! But I have not yet become!
Perhaps the definition of shirk is this very thing!
You must not make anything a partner of your own inner experience!
The only source of truth is inside you!
If you seek truth from outside, you become a polytheist!
Even this very writing — do not accept it until it has become your own experience!
Original (Persian)